Why Is It So Hard to Get Student Loans Discharged in Bankruptcy?

TRI Writer • June 22, 2020

If you are a college student or were a college student and you are facing student loans that seem to far exceed any amount of credit you planned on facing, you’ve probably wondered why it’s so rare to hear of student loans discharged in bankruptcy.

Why Can’t You File Bankruptcy to Get Rid of Student Loan Debt?

Did you know that US borrowers owe a combined $1.59 trillion in student loans? If you are one of the many out there who are contributing to this staggering total, you might be struggling to keep up with your student loan payments. You may even be feeling burdened by the student loan debt and considering filing bankruptcy for relief. However, student loans are rarely dischargeable in bankruptcy.

Why Are Student Loan Debts So Rarely Dischargeable in Bankruptcy?

The first step is identifying if you qualify to file Chapter 7, as opposed to Chapter 13. Petitioners must pass the means test to qualify to file Chapter 7 bankruptcy. The means test measures income against the median income for households of a similar size in the filer’s resident state. If you pass the means test and qualify for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you need to show that you don’t have the financial ability to pay back your student loans in your lifetime or that paying back your student loans in your lifetime would pose an undue financial hardship.

The Brunner Test Can Be Used to Determine Eligibility for Student Loan Discharge:

Most bankruptcy courts use the Brunner Test to decide if student loans are eligible for bankruptcy discharge. Under the Brunner Test, the bankruptcy filer must show that:

  • The student loan borrower has made every reasonable effort to pay their student loan debt.
  • The student loan borrower won’t be able to maintain a reasonable standard of living if they are forced to repay the student loans.
  • The student loan borrower’s current financial hardship won’t go away for the majority of the repayment period.

What This Means for Student Loan Borrowers Filing Bankruptcy:

If you are a student loan borrower considering filing bankruptcy, here’s what all this means for you. Unless you’re very old or you can’t hold down a job because of a permanent disability, you will have a hard time getting a bankruptcy court to agree that your financial situation isn’t likely to change in the future. It’s also important to note that since there are many different interpretations of “reasonable” standard of living, the bankruptcy court may not recognize living at “home” with your parents until you’re 50 or bunking in a friend’s basement with four roommates as an unreasonable standard of living. Additionally, other criteria are open to interpretation. Overall, bankruptcy courts tend to avoid letting student loan borrowers discharge the debt. All these factors together mean that student loan debt is generally considered not dischargeable in bankruptcy.

Can Bankruptcy Still Benefit Overwhelmed Students?

Many students and past students overwhelmed by student loan debt still find bankruptcy beneficial since all eligible debts are discharged, which often leaves them with more discretionary income to work with when attempting to pay down their student loans.

Do you have questions about bankruptcy law and how to manage student loan debt by filing bankruptcy? The experienced Tennessee and Georgia bankruptcy attorneys at Kenneth C. Rannick P.C. can help. We help good people through bad times every day, and we can help you, too.

A statue of justice is sitting on a wooden table.
March 20, 2025
Struggling with debt? Learn seven key signs that it might be time to consider bankruptcy. Kenneth C. Rannick P.C. offers legal guidance to individuals in Chattanooga ready for a financial fresh start.
February 17, 2025
Can I Keep My Car If I File for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Tennessee?
February 1, 2025
What Are My Options If I Am Drowning in Credit Card Debt in Tennessee?
November 21, 2024
What Are the Documents Required to Apply for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Tennessee?
October 29, 2024
What is the Difference Between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy in Tennessee?
June 24, 2024
Understanding Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Qualifications
April 5, 2024
Understanding the Role of the Trustee in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
March 27, 2024
Understanding which Debts can be Discharged in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
February 19, 2024
Protecting Your Assets in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
January 30, 2024
Are you a Tennessee resident facing financial challenges and considering bankruptcy? If so, you may have heard about a relatively new option called Subchapter 5 bankruptcy. But what exactly is Subchapter 5 and how does it differ from traditional Chapter 11 bankruptcy? More importantly, what benefits does it offer to individuals and small businesses?  In this blog post, we will explore the world of Subchapter 5 bankruptcy and shed light on its advantages for Tennessee residents. Whether you're a struggling entrepreneur or an individual burdened by overwhelming debt, understanding the potential benefits of Subchapter 5 can help you make informed decisions about your financial future. What is Subchapter 5 Bankruptcy? Subchapter 5 is a relatively recent addition to the United States Bankruptcy Code, specifically designed to provide a streamlined and cost-effective bankruptcy process for small businesses and individuals. It was created as part of the Small Business Reorganization Act (SBRA) in 2019, with the aim of increasing accessibility to Chapter 11 bankruptcy relief. The Benefits of Subchapter 5 Bankruptcy Simplified Process: One of the key advantages of Subchapter 5 is its simplified and faster bankruptcy process. Unlike traditional Chapter 11 bankruptcy, which can be complex and costly, Subchapter 5 offers a more streamlined approach that is better suited for small businesses and individuals. Retention of Ownership: Under Subchapter 5, business owners have the opportunity to retain ownership and control of their company while developing a repayment plan. This allows for greater flexibility and the ability to restructure debts without losing ownership interests. Reduced Plan Requirements: Subchapter 5 eliminates certain stringent plan requirements that are typically associated with traditional Chapter 11 bankruptcy. This simplification of the plan process makes it more accessible to small businesses and individuals. Debt Repayment Plan: Subchapter 5 allows for the development of a debt repayment plan based on the individual's or small business's disposable income. This plan spans over three to five years, making it more manageable and achievable for debtors. Creditor-Friendly Approach: Subchapter 5 encourages creditor participation and collaboration, promoting consensual resolutions and a more amicable environment. This can lead to increased cooperation, reduced litigation costs, and ultimately, a more successful restructuring process. Subchapter 5 vs. Chapter 11 Bankruptcy: Understanding the Difference While both Subchapter 5 bankruptcy and traditional Chapter 11 bankruptcy share some similarities, there are significant differences between the two. The primary distinction lies in the complexity, cost, and requirements associated with each option. Subchapter 5 offers a more simplified and accessible bankruptcy process specifically tailored to the needs of small businesses and individuals, while Chapter 11 is better suited for larger businesses with more complex financial structures. If you're a Tennessee resident grappling with financial difficulties, Subchapter 5 bankruptcy may provide a viable solution. Its streamlined process, reduced plan requirements, and debtor-friendly approach make it an attractive option for small businesses and individuals seeking relief from overwhelming debt. Before making any decisions, it's essential to consult with a qualified bankruptcy attorney who can guide you through the process and help determine the best course of action for your specific situation. Remember, bankruptcy is not a one-size-fits-all solution, and the outcome will depend on various factors. However, understanding the potential benefits of Subchapter 5 bankruptcy can empower you to make informed decisions about your financial future. At Kenneth C. Rannick, P.C., we specialize in bankruptcy law and can provide the guidance and support you need during challenging times. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and explore your options for a fresh start. Take control of your financial future with Subchapter 5 bankruptcy. Let us help you navigate the path to a brighter tomorrow.
More Posts
Share by: